Issue #64

This is the September 2024 issue of Salon Futura. Here are the contents.


  • Cover: Resurrection Code: This month's cover art is by Ben Baldwin

  • Space Oddity: Decibel Jones and the Absolute Zeroes are back in a new crazy caper. Rock 'n' Roll never read so good.

  • The Sunforge: Book two of Sascha Stronach's Endsong trilogy has arrived, and some of the mysteries from book one are explained.

  • Eyes of the Void: Adrian Tchaikovsky writes books faster than Cheryl can read them, but a dent has been made in the TBR pile.

  • Lyda Morehouse Interview: Cheryl and Lyda chat about Resurrection Code and the influences on the AngeLINK series

  • Star Trek Prodigy – Season #2: The crazy kids are back in the latest animation offering from the Star Trek franchise. And so is the Emergency Holographic Doctor.

  • Speculative Insight: Can you make a paying venue for SF&F non-fiction work? Alex Pierce is the latest to try.

  • The Acolyte: The latest TV series from the Star Wars franchise seems to have bitten off more than it can chew.

  • Editorial – September 2024: In which going to England proves dangerous

Cover: Resurrection Code

This is the cover art that Ben Baldwin produced for Resurrection Code, the fifth book in Lyda Morehouse’s AngeLINK series. The previous four covers had been done by Bruce Jensen. As he wasn’t available this time round, we asked Ben to produce something in the same style. The only other direction he got was that the central figure should be a mouse avatar, and that the background should be Egyptian-themed. He delivered magnificently.

As usual, the unadulterated art is shown below.

Space Oddity

Get your feather boas and glitter ready, folks. It is time for another round of the Metagalactic Grand Prix! Or, in other words, Catherynne M Valente has written a sequel to Space Opera.

To understand these books we need to consider what Eurovision means to people. It can be very different for Europeans and Americans. In particular, for those of us young enough to have seen it live, Abba’s arrival on the Eurovision stage was strongly reminiscent of Dorothy stepping from monochrome Kansas into the glorious Technicolor world of Oz. Music would never be the same again.

For Americans, however, Eurovision is a window on that vast and ancient mystery called European civilization. That is for them, what ancient Egypt is for us: impossibly old and long-lasting, and full of strange and eccentric customs that thrill and delight the tourist. Thankfully, ancient Egypt is no longer with us. If it was, Pharoah TV would have shows such as Mummies for Dummies, Good Morning Kephri (Wake Up and Smell the Dung), and Sekhmet’s Hunting Party. But Europe still shambles along, zombie like, through the world, and thus we have Eurovision in place of The Book of the Dead. Americans have spent decades trying to decode its mysteries. Valente has perhaps come closest to understanding it.

She has also created a version of it that is beyond the wildest imaginings of most entries.

Whereas Adrian Tchaikovsky (see elsewhere in this issue) ramps up danger planets to the max, he still plays by the rules of science. Valente rips up the rule book, cuts it into little confetti unicorns, and scatters it willy-nilly across the face of the universe, daring it to explode them in as creative a way possible, while also humanizing the process with outlandish analogies. Valente asks us things like–and I’m making this one up, her stuff is much better–what if the universe were Los Angeles, and all the stars that never were are parking cars and pumping gas, and are royally pissed about it? What would a royally pissed superheated ball of hydrogen gas behave like?

Along the way she also comes up with some amazing rants. This one about the English language is a particular favourite of mine. I shared it with my Welsh tutor, who also loved it. Welsh might seem a very weird language, but it has its own internal logic. English is just, well…

“That English robs other languages blind, saws off their best vocabularies, and wears them stapled, still dripping, to its own face, is both well-known and not much of a problem for man, mushroom, or Meleg. But English, inasmuch as it has rules, is so constitutionally incapable of obeying even itself that virtually every possible sentence contains some exception, some rude gesture of pug-nosed defiance toward the concept of order itself, some precious little bit of spelling or syntax that thinks it’s so special it doesn’t have to behave like all the other children. You can hardly turn a phrase without being accosted by silent letters lying in wait for innocent spellers-by, half-dressed homonyms beckoning with come-hither stares, red-light district infinitives doing the splits, some dubious fellow in a trench coat lined with irregular verbs, delinquent subclauses loitering in the night, delusional plurals insisting they’re perfectly normal, broken sentence fragments desperate for the love of a good subject, unhinged apostrophes clinging to your clothes, and roving gangs of wildly disparate diphthongs all pronounced eh.”

Quite.

But anyway, what about the plot?

Decibel Jones and the Absolute Zeroes have saved Earth from destruction by not finishing last in the Metagalactic Grand Prix. However, all is not well with our heroes. Oort St. Ultraviolet has gone home to his family. Mira Wonderful Star is alive only because her twenty-something self is stuck in a time loop that allows her to resurrect in the present for limited periods. And as for Dess, he’s in a massive funk because they didn’t win.

You see, that’s the thing about song contests. If you win you can hold your head up high and go on to bigger and better things. But if you don’t, well, that was the pinnacle of your career. From now on there is nothing for it but endless touring of backwater planets where you will play gigs to audiences who prefer corporate hospitality boxes to mosh pits, you will appear on celebrity game shows, and you’ll shoot advertising videos for household cleaning products. In other words, the only reason that you are not actually dead is that one day you might be sufficiently old and infirm and well-loved enough to be asked to come back one last time to headline Glasto.

So Dess is in a massive funk, despite the fact that he has command of a luxury starship on which to conduct his mandated post-contest tour. Foolishly he asks the ship to take him somewhere cool, and the ship drops him in very hot water indeed.

Specifically it causes Dess and his crew to make First Contact with a new intelligent species. That means that there has to be a new Metagalactic Grand Prix, in which Dess’s new “friends” are in danger of having their planet destroyed. And it is Dess’s job to help them through the process.

Along the way we get a look at the internal working of the Galactic Broadcasting Union. It transpires that it is run as a never-ending committee meeting which operates on Rakevat’s Rules of Chaos. Yes, this is a WSFS Business Meeting joke. It is probably also the most Douglas Adams aspect of the book, and Valente generously acknowledges the debt she owes to the master of absurdist SF.

Thankfully(?) for Dess and the crew, Öö the Keshet is on hand to cause even more trouble as only an over-excitable time-traveling red panda-like species can.

If I have a complaint about this book, it is that it resembles a large helping of exceptionally rich Death by Chocolate. Yes, it is delicious, and you can probably manage a couple of helpings. But after that you just have to give it a rest and come back for more tomorrow. That makes reading the book quite slow compared to one that rushed you from one chapter to the next (for example, the new Green Man book from Juliet McKenna, which I also had the pleasure of reading this past month).

That said, Space Oddity features one of the oddest star systems, many of the oddest aliens, and absolutely the best music of any book out there. Somewhere in an alternate universe, David Bowie has read it and loved it.

book cover
Title: Space Oddity
By: Catherynne M Valente
Publisher: Little Brown
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

The Sunforge

I’ve been looking forward to this book for some time. It was clear from the first book in the series, The Dawnhounds, that there was a lot to be learned about the world in which the book is set. In particular, while some of the characters are able to do magic, and attribute this to the favour of gods, it is obvious that the gods are actually people (and therefore not actually gods, if you were at the “Gods in Fantasy” panel at Worldcon).

The middle book of a trilogy is a challenge for authors in many ways. Sascha Stronach has chosen to use hers to reveal the true nature of her world. There is not a lot I can say about this without excessive spoilers, save to say that it is clear why Tamsyn Muir loves these books (other than Kiwi solidarity).

So what can I say? Well, Yat and Sen, from the previous book, are now crew on board the Kopek, which is anchored just off the old imperial capital of Radovan. The ship has just come under serious magical attack. It has barely survived, and Captain Sibbi is missing. Much of the first half of the book is then told in backstory. We get to meet the various characters in Radovan with whom the Kopek crew had been working, and we are given a view of what is happening in the city.

Stronach has perhaps been watching UK politics. Failed empires have a habit of falling into Fascism because Fascist leaders love to talk about how they will restore former glories. In Radovan this means an organization called the Vuruhi who recruit amongst disaffected and violent young men. Naturally they prey on foreigners and queers. It is all very familiar. Thankfully Reform doesn’t have actual paramilitary thugs on the streets yet, but they came close to it over the summer.

This being a fantasy novel, there is a lot more going on behind the scenes, and the Vuruhi are merely pawns in a much bigger game. I suspect that Stronach enjoyed having them come to a nasty end. I would have done.

Some readers will find the book difficult to follow. As in the work of Gene Wolfe and Tamsyn Muir, characters are not always who them seem, because they may be possessed by other characters, or be cloned versions of the people you think they are. Sometimes they swap identities from one paragraph to another. I love this sort of thing, but your mileage may vary.

I should also note that that Stronach uses a number of terms from Pacific cultures with which she is familiar. Not all of them are Māori. And, this being Stronach, there is some excellent trans rep in the book. (And no, it does not center on the possession thing. That’s what a cis writer would have done.)

Book three seems to have been fairly well set up by the end of The Sunforge. I wouldn’t put it past Stronach to pull some major surprises. There is, after all, a story that is much bigger than the one most of the characters know about to be resolved. I’ll be pre-ordering book three as soon as it is announced.

book cover
Title: The Sunforge
By: Sascha Stronach
Publisher: Saga Press
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

Eyes of the Void

I very much enjoyed the first book in Adrian Tchaikovsky’s The Final Architecture series, and bought the other two books as soon as they came out. But they are enormous, which is a bit off-putting when you have a lot of books to read. Thankfully the Best Series Hugo gave me the impetus I needed to get back into the saddle.

In Shards of Earth we are introduced to a future in which the universe is menaced by moon-sized entities called Architects who delight in refashioning planets in bizarre ways, seemingly uncaring about the deaths of everyone living on those planets. Their depredations were stopped 50 years ago when humanity learned to speak to them using specially talented and trained people called Intermediaries, but now they are back and as destructive as ever.

Our heroes in the story are the Intermediary, Idris Telemier, and the rag tag crew of the we’re-not-smugglers-honest ship, Vulture God. They are focused on trying to find out why the Architects have returned, and how they can be persuaded to stop. Meanwhile the various poltical power blocks in the galaxy are arguing amongst themselves. As Tchaikovsky has one of his characters think in Eyes of the Void:

It was as though, in the face of a threat as vast as the Architects, the human mind slid off sideways towards conflicts more winnable.

Replace “Architects” with “Climate Change” and the relevance of the story is immediately obvious.

In this book Idris and his friends follow the trail of the ancient civilization known as the Originators to try to find out more about the Architects. It seems that Architects are unwilling to attack planets that contain Originator remains, so this is obviously a giant clue. Along the way they are pursued by the Bond-like character, Havaer Mundy, who works for the Council of Human Interests (colloquially known as Hugh) and who has his own personal journey through the books.

First up on the tour is a planet called Arc Pallator which has the largest known collection of Originator remains. Archaeology happens, despite the bad behavior of various human and non-human power blocks. However, the expedition creates more questions that answers, and things go badly wrong.

Eventually the plot leads to a world called Cricceth’s Hell, which is a planet that is utterly inimical to life, or indeed any sort of biology. It is a masterpiece of ramping the science up to the max. The point here is that Cricceth’s Hell is such an awful place that no one in their right minds goes there. As a result of which it is home to an actual, functioning Originator settlement. Idris finds himself there as a prisoner of a group of renegades led by one of the giant aliens known as Naeromathi. This character calls himself Ahab due to his absolute obsession with destroying the Architects. The crew of the Vulture God are trying to rescue Idris, but are seriously hampered by a bunch of human oligarchs who think that the Architects are a perfect tool for their unique form of Disaster Capitalism. They have their own version of, “ignore Climate Change, we’ll just terraform Mars.”

It is not much of a spoiler to say that the unique nature of the ruins on Cricceth’s Hell provide Idris with a clue to solving the problem of the Architects. It provides, as the title suggests, eyes on the void of Unspace where the Architects live. The question is, will they be able to do anything about it, or will idiots amongst the human and alien powers get in the way. The final book in the series will presumably have the answer.

book cover
Title: Eyes of the Void
By: Adrian Tchaikovsky
Publisher: Tor
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

Lyda Morehouse Interview

The new edition of Resurrection Code is due for release on October 3rd. Lyda and I are very excited about this, because at last the AngeLINK series has all five books back in print and looking line a set. So we did a podcast to talk about how the book came to be, and why we wanted it as it is.

Along the way we discuss how the ability to get mainstream publishers to accept queer content has changed over the years. There is also discussion of how Lyda’s new book, Welcome to Boy.net, relates to the AngeLINK universe.



Star Trek Prodigy – Season #2

The animation folks at Star Trek have another huge success on their hands. Whereas Lower Decks manages to love Trek whilst thoroughly taking the piss out of it, Prodigy has turned into a classic Trek series with a full-on space opera story arc and plenty of great Trek moments.

If you have seen Season #1 you will remember that the rag tag bunch of kids who are the stars of the series have made it to Federation Space where they hope to become actual Starfleet Academy Cadets. However, events get in the way of this plan, and they find themselves involved in a mission to rescue Chatokay was is trapped in the past with the Protostar. Meanwhile Gwyn gets sent on a diplomatic mission to her home planet, Solum. Inevitably things go badly wrong, and the kids end up creating a time paradox which threatens the stability of the universe. The rest of the series is taken up with their attempts to put things right.

Of course Starfleet did not send a bunch of cadets on a highly sensitive mission by themselves. They are only there because of their knowledge of the Protostar, and Gwyn’s connection to Solum. The mission is supposedly under the command of Admiral Janeway, so a significant part of the story is essentially a “kids have to save their dumb parents” type story, in which Janeway is their over-protective mom, and the Emergency Holographic Doctor is their incompetent dad.

Along the way there is plenty of character development for the kids, including a fascinating evolving relationship between the energy being, Zero, and an arrogant Vulcan pilot who has the highly significant name of Ma’jel. You can’t give a character in Star Trek that name and not have her play a major role in the story.

There are also some very Trek moments. While the series does have a very clear arc, there are a few filler episodes that introduce lighter themes and provide opportunities for character development. One of them involves landing on a planet where a Klingon scientist has accidentally bred a species of giant, carnivorous tribbles.

Because this is a time travel story, it is inevitable that there is a guest appearance by temporal agent extraordinaire, Wesley Crusher. It is also inevitable that one of the first things Janeway says to him when they meet is, “You need to call your mom.”

All in all, it is a great story that had me bingeing through it as fast as I could because I very much wanted to know what happened next. It looks like there will be more, because our heroes get back to Earth just in time for the attack on the Utopia Planitia shipyards, and an excuse for a whole new season is provided.

Both series of Prodigy have been in the form of 20 half-hour episodes. This seems to give plenty of opportunity for story-telling, and somehow a half hour of animation manages to pack in as much story as an hour of live action. Add to that the fact that it is much easier to do interesting aliens with animation, and you’ve got a recipe for a very successful series. I very much hope that Star Trek does more of this sort of thing.

Speculative Insight

One of the things that irritates me about the world is that non-fiction is valued much less highly than fiction. I could see this when I was editing non-fiction for Clarkesworld. It was clear from the reader surveys that a lot of the readers didn’t bother with the content I was acquiring. They just read the fiction. And when I tried running Salon Futura as a paying venue for non-fiction, it quickly became obvious that most SF&F readers were not willing to pay for a non-fiction magazine. You can see the same thing in the wider book-publishing world too. Academics are generally expected to write for free, despite the fact that the books they write are sold for ridiculous amounts. And public historians are moving more and more into what is called “creative non-fiction”. Meanwhile garbage like Ancient Apocalypse gets made for Netflix while actual archaeologists can’t get a look-in.

Human beings love stories, and there doesn’t seem to be much that can be done about that.

However, one brave person is once again trying to create a paying online venue for SF&F non-fiction. Thank you, Alex Pierce and Speculative Insight.

Alex is financing the site in a number of ways. While some of the content is free, other essays are behind a paywall. In addition, you can now buy a collected edition of January-June 2024 content as either an ebook or paperback. Alex also had books available at Worldcon, and they seemed to be going well.

Obviously I am a bit biased here, because an essay of mine was the first thing that Speculative Insight published, but there has been lots of other content since then. For Terry Pratchett fans, Tansy Rayner Roberts has a series of essays about the male supporting characters in the Witches books. Tansy is always good value on feminist issues. There’s also an essay on Flemish folklore, which is something very new to me.

On the science fiction side of things, there are essays about Murderbot, Diversity in Star Trek, the future of Solarpunk, and the type of spaceships that are likely to exist, assuming that inter-stellar travel was possible. And much more.

If you already have a subscription, there’s a lure for you to buy the book as well in the form of a bonus essay from Lisa L Hannett. This looks at themes of childbirth and parenting in science fiction, contrasting them with Lisa’s own experience of a rather challenging birth. I suspect that it qualifies as creative non-fiction, but it is rather good (albeit with trigger warnings for anyone contemplating pregnancy for the first time).

As far as I can see, the books are only available from the Speculative Insight website. And as Alex is based in Australia it would make sense for most of us to get the ebook. I do hope it sells well. I want to see people writing good non-fiction about SF&F, and it won’t happen unless there is some means of people getting paid for it.

The Acolyte

I really wanted to like this series. It had Carrie-Ann Moss. It featured a trans actress (Abigail Thorn). There was significant writing and production involvement for Jen Richards, who is one of the most successful trans women in Hollywood. It would really have annoyed the dudebros had the show been a big success.

Sadly, it wasn’t. I think it may have worked better as a book, as that would have given the ambitious plot more room in which to develop character motivations. As it was, and 8-episode series didn’t give the story enough room to breath. Consequently, when we finally got to the point of finding out what really happened on Brendok 16 years ago, the whole thing kind of fell apart.

The highlight of the series was Amandla Stenberg who played both the lead characters: the twin sisters Osha and Mae. She deserved better from the series. So did Dafne Keen whose Jecki was one of the more interesting characters in the series, and who was randomly killed off because someone had to be the red shirt.

I’m also somewhat sad that the idea of interrogating the downfall of the Jedi order by focusing on the inability of individual Jedi to live up to the order’s moral code is not going to go anywhere. Having said that, I suspect that the idea was unpopular with quite a few people within the Star Wars organization. It is hardly very Joseph Campbell.

I understand from Wikipedia that a couple of tie-in novels based on the setting of The Acolyte have been commissioned. Possibly these will provide more insight into the character motivations and the rot within the Jedi order, but I can’t imagine that I will have the time to read them.

Editorial – September 2024

The plan was that, once Kevin had been safely delivered to Heathrow, I would have several weeks in September to get caught up on stuff. Sadly things didn’t work out like that.

We had both done Worldcon and been fine. We had spent three weeks touring Wales, including attending Carmarthen Pride, and been fine. Then we went to London. Kevin, thankfully, managed to avoid getting infected, but I spent the next two weeks recovering from a bout of COVID. It was very annoying.

It was also quite odd. I had very little in the way of symptoms. Indeed, had I not just been to England I might have assumed it was just a cold or allergies and not tested. So then I had two weeks of feeling mostly fine waiting for it to go away. I can see how so many people are wandering around sick and spreading it.

One thing I am pleased about in this issue is that I have got back into doing podcast interviews. Hopefully this will once again become a regular feature of the magazine.

The good side of this is that I should now be safe for the four events, including three conventions, that I have to go to in the next 5 weekends. October is going to be rough.

Issue #63

This is the August 2024 issue of Salon Futura. Here are the contents.


Cover: Future Ruins

For this issue’s cover we are back to Pixabay and a very nice far future archaelogists piece from Gordon Taylor. As usual, you can find out more about the artist by these convenient links:

Image by Gordon Taylor from Pixabay

I had to crop the image somewhat to make it cover-shaped. The full image is displayed below.



Echo of Worlds

Here is a book that I have been eagerly waiting for some time, and now find very difficult to review. Mike Carey’s Pandominium duology is not two separate novels, it is one long novel split in two for publication purposes, and with some shock reveals at the end of part 1 that make talking about part 2 in a spoiler-free way quite challenging.

OK, let’s start with a recap. Infinity Gate introduced us to a multiverse in which infinite versions of Earth exist and where intelligent life has taken very different evolutionary routes in each universe. Two of our heroes—Hadiz and Essien—are humanoid. Of the other two, Moon is a felid (a cat) and Topaz is a lagomorph (a rabbit). The cast also includes Rupshe, an AI accidentally created by Hadiz, and a second AI whose identity is revealed in the first book.

The primary source of conflict in the books is the fact that there are some worlds in the multiverse where the dominant form of life is mechanical rather than biological. We thus have conflict between the Pandominium (a vaguely democratic association of worlds inhabited by biological lifeforms) and the Machine Hegemony (a collection of worlds inhabited by a hive mind of intelligent machines). Both sides believe that the other side is inhabited by creatures that class as vermin rather than self-aware intelligent entities, and so both sides want to utterly destroy the other.

The points that Carey is making here should be obvious, but he’s not doing it in a preachy way so you don’t feel that you are being hit over the head with the message.

Infinity Gate takes us through the initial discovery of the true nature of the book world, and conflict that is about to engulf it. Echo of Worlds is about the efforts that our heroes make to avoid that catastrophe. Do they manage to do so? Yes, of course. Are billions of innocent lives nevertheless lost in the process? Also yes. This is space opera. You can’t get by without destroying a few worlds.

There is only one significant new character introduced in Echo of Worlds. This is Mother Mass, not quite a living planet, but absolutely a planet inhabited by a single, enormous biological entity. She (they?) is the sort of thing I can imagine Kirk and Spock encountering in Star Trek.

The way in which the plot is resolved should be fairly obvious early on, though there are some good shock reveals along the way. What is more interesting is the way in which you start to see how everything has been carefully set up from the beginning. It is a masterful exercise in plotting.

Those of you who enjoyed the relationship between Hadiz and Essien in the first book may be disappointed that it has no further to go, but then how could it? Of more interest in book two is how Essien becomes more of a conscience for Moon who, being feline, has a passion for killing things with extreme prejudice. However, the primary focus of book two is on Paz. She turns out to be rather more competent than one might expect for a sixteen-year-old girl, even one who is a rabbit, but she’s a great character so I didn’t mind too much.

Overall this is a very fine pair of books, and I’m rather sad that we won’t be able to treat them as a single work for award periods, because a single work is undoubtedly what they are.

book cover
Title: Echo of Worlds
By: Mike Carey
Publisher: Orbit
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

Beyond the Light Horizon

When I reviewed Beyond the Reach of Earth, the second volume in Ken MacLeod’s Lightspeed Trilogy, I found myself asking why there will be a book three. Clearly there were unanswered questions at the end of that book, but exactly which ones MacLeod would pick up and run with was another matter entirely. As it turned out, Beyond the Light Horizon is something else entirely.

Obviously the themes raised in the first two books still exist. The three main political power blocks: the Union, the Alliance and the Co-Ord, are still competing ferociously for access to territory, resources and technology. That, MacLeod suggests, will be a constant feature of the world as long as those power blocks exist. Interestingly, he also adds the African Union to the mix. They are not on the same level as the other three, but with careful politicking they could get there.

We also have the mystery of the Fermi to be resolved. The new book does explain who they are and how they came to be. But it is their motivation, hinted at in book 2, that is most important.

There is also the ongoing tension between the entrepreneurial spirit of John Grant, and the fact that he lives in a very socialist society. The way in which the two co-exist will doubtless be the subject of academic papers in the future.

However, the main thrust of Beyond the Light Horizon is the issue of colonialism. Thanks to the invention of the FTL drive, human beings have been able to reach out into the galaxy and find new worlds to exploit. We have already seen questions about the colony on Apis, and those will multiply. There is also the question as to what happens when mankind, inevitably, encounters other advanced, sentient species. (This being MacLeod, who loves to play with the silly end of popular conceptions of aliens, one such race are dinosaurs.)

There are no neat and simple answers at the end of this series. MacLeod makes it clear that humans will always be on the look out for an opportunity to enrich themselves. Even older and presumably wiser intelligent species may be tempted. And while many individuals might want to do the right thing, there will always be powerful factions that want to maintain their power by any means possible. Some readers may be put off by what seems like a non-ending, but I’m pretty sure that what MacLeod wants us to do is go away and think about the issues he has presented, not to ask him for a pre-packed solution.

book cover
Title: Beyond The Light Horizon
By: Ken MacLeod
Publisher: Orbit
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

A Marvellous Light

I was familiar with all of the Best Series finalists for this year’s Hugos bar one: The Last Binding by Freya Marske. Therefore I decided to give the first book a try. A Marvelous Light could probably be described as being in the subgenre of English Magic fantasies. Like Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell, it centers on the fact that some people in England (upper class people, obviously) have preserved magical skills over the ages and now (in this case in Edwardian times rather than Georgian) this is becoming a matter of political importance.

Our hero, Sir Robin Blyth, is an impoverished minor aristocrat who civil service career takes a turn for the weird when he is appointed to a small and secretive department responsible for magical affairs. It turns out that his predecessor in the post, one Reginald Gatling, has disappeared without trace. We readers, as we have more viewpoints than Robin, know that poor Reggie has probably been murdered by magicians.

So much for the plot, but this is not what the book is about. A Marvelous Light is a gay romance, centering on the relationship between Robin and his prickly new boss, Edwin Courcey. I think by now you are used to my opinions on romance, though Marske does handle the tropes better than some I have read. Worse still, from my point of view, the book is verging on erotica. Reader, I have absolutely zero interest in what gay men do in bed together. At least that meant I got the book read more quickly as I was able to skip large chunks.

I wasn’t hugely impressed with the worldbuilding either. For people in a highly important government department with direct access to the Prime Minister, Blyth and Courcey seem remarkably powerless.

So far, so disheartening, and yet I quite enjoyed the book. That’s partly down to the characters, and partly down to the way that Marske portrays the agonies of two gay men in a deeply homophobic society. This is not a “the past was gay because I want it to be” book, it makes a serious attempt to engage with how being closeted messes with your mind.

The other thing I really liked about the book is the departmental secretary who works for Blyth and Courcey. Adelaide Morrissey is, inevitably, far more competent than her bosses. She is also, despite the name, of Indian extraction. I would have liked to see more of her.

Book 2 in the series, A Restless Truth, features Robin Blyth’s headstrong teenage sister, Maud. It is likely to be of more interest to me, even if it is still a romance. I might give it a try.

book cover
Title: A Marvellous Light
By: Freya Marske
Publisher: Tor
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

Rose/House

There was some pretty stiff competition in the Novella category for the Hugos this year. I have already reviewed Thornhedge, Mammoths at the Gates, and The Mimicking of Known Successes, all of them favourably. But there was also an Arkady Martine story on the list, and I’ve loved everything of hers I have read. How would Rose/House stack up to the others?

I should start by noting that there is a really interesting review of the book at Strange Horizons that examines aspects of the book that did not occur to me when I read it. Thank you, Vanessa Jae, it is always interesting to get a new perspective on a work.

My thoughts on reading the book, rather more obviously, was that it was about billionaires and AIs. Rose House itself is an AI, and was created by a reclusive billionaire, possibly one who was an actual genius, rather than a self-styled genius like a certain real world billionaire I could mention. But even a genius can’t create incredible things without lots of money. To create something incredible by yourself requires absurd amounts of money. Basit Deniau, the creator of Rose House, while now deceased, exhibits exactly the sort of egomania we have come to expect from the fabulously wealthy.

So we have a house that is an AI, and also a potential murder suspect. How does a house kill someone, and why? Also how does a detective go about interrogating something that isn’t human, and thinks very differently than humans. That’s doubtless a topic that has been addressed before (presumably by Asimov), but that will always be worth revisiting, especially in these days when people claim (rather absurdly) to have produced actual AIs.

Then we get to the dénouement, and without being too spoilery I think I can say that where billionaires and amazing inventions are concerned, it all comes down to money, and to other people wanting a share of it. It also reminded me somewhat of Kathleen Ann Goonan’s wonderful Flower Cities series.

Rose/House is a clever, thoughtful book that may well have other depths that I have not noticed. It is a worthy competitor in the category. By now, of course, the voters have spoken. But if you didn’t read this one, do give it a try.

book cover
Title: Rose/House
By: Arkady Martine
Publisher: Tor
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

Worldcon #82

While I have been to many Worldcons, this was the first one at which I have been a dealer. The experience is very different. It is also my first post-COVID Worldcon, which also changed things a lot.

Usually Worldcon for me has meant attending a few panels during the day, browsing the Dealers’ Room, Fan Tables and Art Show in the gaps, then going out for dinner and attending parties in the evening. This year, with one small exception, I was in the Dealers’ Room from when it opened until it closed. After that I was so tired that on most days I grabbed a quick meal from the food trucks and fell into bed. Not that I actually wanted to spend time in bars or at parties, as I was pretty sure that they would be prime sites of infection.

From a COVID point of view, the Dealers’ Room was a good deal. The hall had a high ceiling, lots of ventilation, and some doors open to the outside. This was a relief because I needed to spend a lot of time talking to people and I’m not easily understood when wearing a mask as my voice is quite quiet.

Not having attended a Worldcon as a dealer before, I didn’t have much idea of what to expect. I just stuffed my car with as much as I could carry and hoped for the best. As it turned out, I sold around 170 books, and sold out of a number of titles. I was very pleased. That was despite being given a pitch way at the back of the hall where some people never ventured. I noticed that I was placed close to Bona Books, AK Faulkner and Sandra Bond, which made our part of the hall something of a queer ghetto. But The Portal Bookshop was much nearer the front so I don’t think this was anything deliberate on the part of the convention.

The one thing that was slightly annoying about the arrangements was the issue of at-table events. We were told very firmly before the convention that we were not permitted to hold events at our dealer tables. This was to avoid queues for author signings clogging up the alleyways between the tables. Nevertheless, some larger publishers did arrange such events, advertised them widely, and were allowed to get away with it. I totally understand the concern about space, and have been at Worldcons where queues at tables would have been a massive problem. But in Glasgow we had a huge amount of space. There wasn’t any need for that rule, and enforcing it selectively just penalized smaller dealers.

I had one panel. Roz & Jo kindly looked after the table for a couple of hours while I was away. The panel was on Gods and Faith in Fantasy. Besides me it featured Dr. Meg MacDonald (who has a PhD in the very subject of the panel) and Wole Tabali, with Ehud Maimon as moderator. It was great fun, and we good some really good feedback. I hope to catch up with some of the other panels on replay, but this far the only one I have seen is the History of LGBT+ SF&F one, which is hilarious, at least in part as Trip and Chris were asleep on their feet when they did it.

I did also briefly attend one fan party. That was because Pride Space is a project backed by San Francisco Science Fiction Conventions Inc., and Wizard’s Tower was sponsoring the party. I didn’t stay long. I was too tired.

Kevin spent almost the entire convention in the Business Meeting. How he managed to do so and yet remain sane and free of COVID is a mystery to me. Apparently it went about as well as could be expected, given that executing people for engaging in Recreational Parliamentary Practice while people are trying to get important stuff done is not allowed. Most importantly it appears that none of the miscreants from Chengdu have been given an excuse to sue the Worldcon. Hopefully they will eventually be dealt with in a manner that doesn’t put any conventions at risk.

Aside from move-in and move-out, the one thing we got to do together was attend the Hugos. Of course the last time that Worldcon was in Glasgow (2005), the ceremony took place in the starship WSFS Armadillo, and Kevin and I were running Events. The time before that (1995) we went to the Hugos for our first date.

Attending the ceremony when you have been in charge of it means that you see it in a very different way to the average punter. Things were done differently; sometimes for the better, and sometimes not so.

One big change is that Glasgow did away with the role of Toastmaster. There was no overall host for the ceremony. Various presenters rotated through the evening, each controlling the stage in turn. The slot at the beginning in which the Toastmaster normally tells some jokes was replaced by John Scalzi doing a 5 minute history of the Hugos. John is very amusing, so it went pretty well, though because it had to be very quick he inadvertently added to the suggestion that Kevin and I were somehow partly responsible for the Hugos in Chengdu. He also seemed to mangle Cheryl’s Second Law of Fandom. For those who have forgotten, here are the Three Laws again. I think you’ll agree that they are even more true now than they were in 2008 when I first devised them.

  1. Never accept accident or incompetence as an explanation when a bizarre and complex conspiracy can also be advanced to explain the known facts.
  2. One data point indicates a dangerous trend that must be resisted; two data points indicate a sacred and holy tradition that must be preserved.
  3. If a tree falls in Central Park, New York, is seen to fall by 100 New Yorkers, is captured on film by CNN and the video of the fall is broadcast around the world, but I wasn’t there to see it, then it didn’t fall.

I’m not sure that doing away with the Toastmaster adds anything to the ceremony, but it does free up money to have a more varied set of GoHs so it might be worth doing.

Something that may be a really good idea, and I understand was first done in Chengdu, is to have the roll-call of the names of the finalists pre-recorded. This relieves the presenter of the need to learn how to pronounce all those names. They just have to get the name of the winner right. The downside is that, having been relieved of the need to read the names of the finalists, some of the presenters clearly did no prep at all, and one badly mangled the name of the winner despite having just heard it read out.

The thing that everyone at the ceremony will remember is the tech failure on the pre-recorded video. One of the presenters, Catherine Heymans, the Astronomer Royal for Scotland, was unable to be at the convention in person. She had pre-recorded some video, and tech was unable to play any of it. Because of this, there was no envelope on stage, and the people doing their best to cover ended up reading the plaque on the trophy to find out who won.

Kudos is due here to Meganne Christian, who had presented some awards earlier and came back on stage to take control of the chaos. You can tell she’s an astronaut, she was utterly calm and decisive in a crisis.

What most people in the audience probably didn’t notice was that there was no other recorded video. That means no clips of the Best Dramatic Presentation finalists. That’s probably a good thing as they eat up a lot of time in the ceremony, and devour an absurd amount of volunteer time trying to get permission to show them. It also meant no acceptance speeches from people who could not attend the convention. It seems highly unlikely that none of the absent winners would have wanted to say anything, so I have to assume that Glasgow did not give them the opportunity. That seems churlish, except that presumably those videos would not have worked either.

The new Best Game or Interactive Work Hugo seems to have gone down well. Unlike the last time this was trialed, there was a lot of interest in the category. Also the winners, from Larian Studios who produced Baldur’s Gate 3, turned up in force to accept the trophy. This was a big shock. Most of us Worldcon veterans had assumed that video game companies, like Hollywood studios, would not care about the Hugos. Larian were clearly delighted to have won.

I’m not going to comment on the results much. They are what they are, and they are voted on by fans. Besides, the novel that I placed first actually won this year, which is a rarity. Of course the best novel of last year, The Library of Broken Worlds by Alaya Dawn Johnson, barely made it onto the “also ran” list in the Lodestar. Your mileage may vary. I am, however, deeply delighted that Juliet McKenna’s Green Man series was on the “also ran” list for Best Series. Thank you, everyone who voted for it.

The Emerald City Best Dressed at the Hugos Award went to Adri Joy for her magnificent jellyfish hat. I’d like to see someone try to top that.

That’s about all I have to say, because I didn’t see most of the convention. I understand from other reports that it was generally very well received. The two major areas of complaint were the usual suspects complaining about Worldcon having “gone woke”, and people upset at having caught COVID. The former were likely to complain no matter what happened, and I suspect that the only way to attend Worldcon and guarantee not to get sick is to attend virtually. UK fandom is probably less rigorous about masking that Americans, but it is in bar spaces where everyone is packed together and is unmasked because they are drinking and talking that you are most likely to catch the virus.

Finncon 2024

It is great to be back. One of the worst things about the pandemic was that I could not make my regular trips to Finland. I have been suffering sauna-deprivation.

This year Finncon was in Jyväskylä which meant that my good friend Irma Hirsjärvi was involved in the organization. I absolutely could not miss that. Also one of the Guests of Honour was Ursula Vernon, and I’ve been wanting a chance to chat to her about the Sworn Soldier books, and about weird animals.

Talking to Ursula was easy. It turned out that she and her husband, Kevin, were taking the train from Helsinki to Jyväskylä. I needed to do the same, so I volunteered to go along as a “local” guide. As it turned out, we only made it as far as Tampere, but that was because Irma came to collect us and take us to the Moomin Museum. They have done a lot of work on it since I was last there. I warmly recommend it.

First up for me at the convention was the academic conference, which is how I ended up reading Ghost Stories for Darwin (reviewed elsewhere in this issue). That was Friday morning sorted.

In the afternoon I headed off to the Writers’ House for the traditional “On Writing” panel. This part of the con is supposedly aimed at professional writers, but a lot of fans come along too. I got to interview Ursula, which meant that we got to talk about Sworn Soldiers and weird animals in public. As I recall, Ursula knew about the paper nautilus, but the Spanish mole story was new to her. I live in hope of it turning up in a Hugo acceptance speech one day. (If you are not familiar with these animals, you need to buy Worlds Apart: Worldbuilding in Fantasy and Science Fiction from Luna Press and read my essay on “Worldbuilding with Sex and Gender”).

Finncon proper was very much as expected. There were lots of young people in costume. There were many interesting panels. The good folks from Rosebud had tables groaning with books. It was all very pleasant. I gave a lecture entitled “Wales in the Time of Arthur”, which had an audience of around 120. I also participated in the LGBTQ+ Fiction panel. And of course I got to help judge the masquerade.

Much fun was had. Much sauna was had. I got to eat at Harald. And I went to a really interesting panel on Hopepunk, which I shall write about separately.

After the con I delivered Ursula and Kevin back to Helsinki Airport, and then spent a week at an Assyriology conference at Helsinki University. That was also fun, but in a very different way.

Ghost Stories for Darwin

I owe this one to Finncon, or more precisely to the traditional academic conference that takes places on the Friday before Finncon. Irma messaged me to tell me that one of the papers was about Oryx and Crake, and this strange academic book, neither of which I was familiar with. Could I help? Well, I had some memory of reading Oryx and Crake, and being deeply unimpressed. But as for this Ghost Stories for Darwin thing? A book on evolutionary biology written by a woman with a very Indian name. WTF? As I believe people say these days.

My expectations were not improved when I started to read the book on the train to Jyväskylä. I explained to Ursula Vernon and her husband, Kevin, why I would have my nose in a book during the trip. They looked at me as if I had just confessed some sort of masochist fetish. What good could possibly come of this bizarre exercise in self-immolation?

I have to admit that I wasn’t expecting much myself. I have always viewed evolutionary biologists as being insecure white men who are racist, misogynist, queerphobic and ableist, and who invent pseudoscientific theories to justify their bigotries; said theories being provable as correct solely by the existence of patriarchy.

Thankfully I soon changed my mind. Banu Subramaniam grew up in India and traveled to the USA to pursue a PhD in evolutionary biology. She was, by her own admission, naive and starry-eyed. She saw the USA as being a land free of the classism she was familiar with in India, she saw science as being a discipline free of sexism, and she had no idea about the level of racism in US culture. That she survived the experience is a testament to her strength of will, and also to the support she gained from the Women’s Studies department in her university.

Subramaniam’s subject for her PhD was the Morning Glory, a plant closely related to the notorious British Convolvulus, hated by gardeners throughout the land. The convolvulus does have very pretty white flowers (there will probably be lots in my back yard when I get home), but the morning glory has a wide variety of flower colourations, and it is these that Subramaniam was planning to study.

Doing so, and in the process experiencing life as a woman of colour in the USA, led to a political awakening that has established Subramaniam as one of the foremost experts on gender in the sciences. And if that immediately brings to mind the phrase, “women in science”, well you are exactly the sort of ill-informed person that Ghost Stories for Darwin is intended for.

I should note at the start that the book does not entirely succeed. Subramaniam is not a professional science communicator, and there are times, particularly when she is talking about her own academic specialisms, that she veers into complex jargon. Thankfully I have a science degree and was able to make sense of most of it, but other readers may find it very hard going.

Being an academic book, Ghost Stories for Darwin has a subtitle. It is, The Science of Variation and The Politics of Diversity. This is a good place to start looking at the argument. One of the great debates within evolutionary biology is the role of variation in evolution. Some people in the field believe that diversity has an evolutionary advantage for the species, as that provides a wide range of mutations to help it evolve into something better. Others believe that all variation is bad, and that only the fittest variation should be allowed to pass its genes on to new generations. This latter view leads inevitably to eugenics.

But, and here is our first important feminist lesson of the day, all binaries are false. Neither of the explanations above helps us understand why variation in the colour of morning glory flowers persists through hundreds of generations, and can exhibit stable shares of the population to which the species will return if the balance is perturbed. Variation in flower colour appears to be baked in to the morning glory as a species.

The answer to this conundrum is that evolution is not just driven by genetics. It is also influenced by a range of environmental factors including, but not limited to, climate, pollinator preference, soil conditions, human cultivation and so on. Subramaniam quickly discovered that the scientific ideas of doing a simple, one-variable experiment on a field of morning glory flowers tells you nothing.

Exploring the underlying assumptions of her field, and seeking support as a doubly marginalized person within US academia, led Subramaniam both to discover the horrendous eugenicist underpinning of her discipline, and the fundamentally masculinist nature of science as it is practiced.

One interesting aspect of Subramaniam’s section on eugenics is the fact that many of the pioneers of the field saw themselves as striving for a better world, and even as being good Socialists. The idea that the socially inferior should, for their own good, not be allowed to survive, is deeply seductive. While most of the extreme horrors perpetrated in the name of this belief have been minority ethnic groups, the differently abled and queer communities can recognise the syndrome. There have been many times when I have been told that my life would have been easier had I not been born.

Subramaniam moves on from eugenics to matters of race, and the complicated discipline known as Invasion Biology. We are all, I am sure, familiar with stories about how our native ecosystems are being “invaded” by dangerous foreign plants that are “taking over” and “crowding out” native species. Would it surprise you that there is a direct correlation between the frequency of such stories in the newspapers and the level of popular concern about human immigration? And the two types of story use exactly the same types of language.

Of course migration of plant species around the world has a long and in many cases glorious history. Where would our cuisines be without the potato, the tomato, and the chili pepper, all of which were unknown outside the Americas before Columbus accidentally ran into them on his way to India. The famous Georgia Peach is an immigrant from China. The same is true for animal species, though sometimes a little creative marketing is required. The Patagonia Toothfish was unheard of in restaurants before it cleverly changed its name to the Chilean Sea Bass.

The final section of the book is about gender, and it focuses on how the practice of science has been socially constructed in a very masculine fashion. A woman wishing to practice science has to buy into that construction and present herself as “one of the boys” in order to be taken seriously as a scientist. She must not wear make-up, she must not show emotion, and so on. Or at least, she should do so inside the lab. Outside the lab, in social spaces, she must present as conventionally feminine. After all, she will soon want to give up her career and become a wife and mother instead.

Feminist lesson two of the day is that all too often talk of gender focuses solely on the “woman problem”. It talks about how women must change themselves in order to fit into the masculine world, or about the accommodations that must be made for women because they do things like have families. (Men never have families, they have wives to do that for them.) Subramaniam says:

[…] the consistent emphasis on family and women reinforces essentialist ideas about women. What has remained unchallenged is the normative model of the male as the ideal scientist, which insists on productivity that can only be achieved by very long hours, a singular dedication to work, and an exclusive focus on one’s profession.

It occurs to me that many of the lessons Subramaniam presents about life in academia, particularly about the sink-or-swim culture of graduate education, are equally applicable outside of the sciences. Indeed, the failure of senior staff to properly train their subordinates in anything other than the technical aspects of the job at hand (and not in how to do things like be a good manager) is endemic in the world of work at large.

Ghost Stories for Darwin was published in 2014, and there are probably areas where its analysis of academic culture in the USA are out of date. In particular, while Subramaniam did see the commercialization of universities coming, she did not know how close it would come to destroying the institutions it was supposed to rescue.

I noted also that there is very little discussion of sexuality as a marginalized identity. Subramaniam does note that it is an issue, but when she actually talks about it she tends to do so by contrasting the profoundly asexual nature of laboratory life with the expectation of normative heterosexuality outside of the lab. She does make brief note of the famous trans masculine neurobiologist, Ben Barres, to illustrate just how foolish misogynist ideas of what makes a good scientist are, but her discussion of gender is primarily limited to performance rather than identity.

These, however, are minor quibbles. Ghost Stories for Darwin is a fascinating and well-argued book that gave me lots of useful pointers as to how to think about gender and its effects on the world.

Which leaves us with one question: where do the ghosts come in? It turns out that Subramaniam has borrowed the metaphor from Bollywood cinema. In a Bollywood movie, a ghost is always someone who has been unjustly forgotten and ignored after their death, and perhaps in life. They desperately want to be listened to, understood, acknowledged, and recognized so that they can stop haunting the living and rest in peace. The history of feminism, in all areas of life, is a story of Bollywood ghosts.

book cover
Title: Ghost Stories for Darwin
By: Banu Subramaniam
Publisher: University of Illinois Press
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

What Is Hopepunk?

For me, the most interesting panel at Finncon was the one on Hopepunk. It is not a genre that I have paid much attention to in the past. I had a vague idea that to qualify as Hopepunk a book had to be unchallenging, heartwarming and relentlessly positive, after the manner of a Travis Baldree novel. This panel disabused me of that notion, and also got me thinking that Wizard’s Tower might have published some Hopepunk.

Please note that this essay will contain some spoilers for Welcome to Boy.net and Generation Nemesis.

The term, Hopepunk, was first coined by Alexandra Rowland in 2017 as a counter to Grimdark, and the official definition, at least according to Wikipedia, is that Hopepunk books are about, “characters fighting for positive change, radical kindness, and communal responses to challenges”. There’s nothing necessarily soft and fluffy about that. What I learned from the panel, and the Wikipedia entry, is that Hopepunk practitioners have embraced the necessity to fight for a positive future.

What I took away from this is the idea that to qualify as Hopepunk, a book (or other work) has to show belief that a better world is possible, and can be achieved by people acting in a positive, progressive and cooperative way. This does relate well to the original concept, because the primary ethos of Grimdark is that, no matter what anyone does, things will always turn out badly.

So how does this relate to Wizard’s Tower? Firstly I would like to point readers at Lyda Morehouse’s Welcome to Boy.net. On the face of it, this is hardly a cuddly book. It features a pair of lesbian bounty hunters fighting against an oppressive military dictatorship that wants to take over the Solar System. One of our heroines is a former senior officer in that society who defected so that she could undergo gender transition. It all seems rather grim.

But, and this is the thing I loved most about the book when I first read it, while Lucia del Toro does occasionally have to make use of her cyborg abilities, this is not how our heroines win the day. Victory is achieved, not through force of arms, but through the citizens of the free colonies of the Asteroid Belt refusing to be cowed by thugs in uniforms. There is political protest. People get out on the street with banners. That is not the usual ending for a piece of space opera. And it very much suggests that a better world is possible if we all work together for it.

The other book that I want to discuss is Sean McMullen’s Generation Nemesis. That’s a book that has been getting very negative responses when I’ve talk to people about it at conventions. It is, after all, set in a world in which Earth’s climate has been comprehensively wrecked, and vast numbers of people have died. It seems that a lot of people don’t want to admit that climate collapse is now likely, and prefer to read books in which it is not an issue, or where it is somehow prevented. Sean takes what I think is a more realistic view. We are probably already past the point of no return. The question now is how we deal with it.

The plot of Generation Nemesis suggests that humanity will react with anger, and that young people who have seen themselves denied the sort of future that their ancestors enjoyed, will turn upon the old. Drawing on the Terror of the French Revolution, Sean creates a world in which the only choices facing the elderly are a matter of how soon, and how horribly, they are executed.

And yet the book is not without hope. The plot revolves around the attempts of the scientist hero, Jason Hall, to convince the climate courts that revenge is a wasteful strategy. While a few elderly people are indeed wasters in every sense of the word, most of them have some useful skills and can be useful to a society that desperately needs all the help it can get to adapt to the radically different world it has inherited. If the book has a message, it is that humanity can survive climate collapse, but only if we all work together rather than turning on each other. That sounds like Hopepunk to me.

Of course your mileage may differ. And I’m not advertising either book as Hopepunk. That’s partly because I find such labels limiting, and partly because I don’t want to get into any fannish fights about whether the books deserve the label. However, hopefully this essay will help you see both books in a different light. I know that the Finncon panel did that for me. My thanks to Xan van Rooyen for organizing it.

Editorial – August 2024

Well, Worldcon happened. Not doing an issue last month was definitely a wise idea. And in fact it was touch and go whether I would get one out this month. Kevin has been staying with me since Worldcon, so I have been having a life outside of work for a change. It is very nice, but it means that I haven’t read or written much since getting back from Glasgow. Thankfully I had banked a few articles in July.

Worldcon went pretty well, as I explain in my con report. But things have been quite busy since I got back because I needed to process the accounts and order a lot more stock. The latter was quite urgent as I need copies of some books for Carmarthen Pride which is taking place tomorrow (Saturday 31st). Also I have a bunch of new books to get ready for BristolCon. If all goes well, I will have four new books on sale there. Plus I have a bunch of people interested in being published by Wizard’s Tower. That’s partly thanks to Juliet McKenna winning Best Novel in the BSFA Awards, and partly thanks to issues with other publishers. Wizard’s Tower was founded to help mid list authors who were being dropped by their publishers, so I am very happy to be able to help out again.

I won’t be at any conventions in September. Next issue will have more news about BristolCon, and about Fantastika in Stockholm the following weekend where Juliet will be a Guest of Honour. Nordic readers, I can’t import books into the EU, but the English Bookstore in Stockholm is able to do so and they will be handling getting copies of Juliet’s books for sale.

Finally I should say something about the ongoing Neil Gaiman situation. I haven’t said anything to date, partly because trying to explain things on social media is fairly pointless, and partly because I am just too angry. I’m angry with Neil, primarily for the way he treated those young women, but also for other reasons, including the damage this affair has done to the trans cause. I’m also angry with a whole bunch of other people who have pitched in in various unhelpful ways. Maybe when I have calmed down more about it I will say more.

What I will say is that the TERFs are not in this to protect women. Indeed, their insistence that trans women are the primary threat to the safety of cis women provides a valuable smokescreen for government who can claim to be doing something about VAWG (by removing trans rights) while leaving cis men free to continue preying on women unfettered. Having seen the way that TERFs have exploited vulnerable detransitioners, I am very worried about those of Neil’s victims who have fallen into their clutches.

Issue #62

This is the June 2024 issue of Salon Futura. Here are the contents.


  • Cover: Mary Ellen, Craterean!: The cover is taken from Ben Baldwin's art for the latest Crater School book

  • What Feasts at Night: The new Alex Easton novella sees our hero once again in the wilds of Gallacia, though this time without the homicidal mushrooms

  • Queering Faith in Fantasy Literature: The Centre for Fantasy and the Fantastic at the University of Glasgow is producing some very interesting books, including this one

  • Waypoint Seven: A new space opera novella from a Finland-based author and a South African small press

  • Unexploded Remnants: Elaine Gallagher's debut novella is space opera with a strong Indiana Jones influence

  • Tolkien Lecture 2024: This year's Tolkien Lecture was given by Neil Gaiman. Cheryl was there.

  • The Book Blinders: John Clute is justifibly angry about the vandalism perpetrated by the British Library upon its collection of books

  • Doctor Who 15-1: As always, some people absolutely adore the new incaration of The Doctor, while others hate him

  • 3 Body Problem – Netflix: The people who allegedly ruined A Game of Thrones on TV have turned their hands to a famous science fiction trilogy

  • Furiosa: More gorgeous Australian scenery, more car chases, but does Furiosa have anything new to offer

  • Editorial – June 2024: There will be no July issue, but hopefully a bumper one in August

What Feasts at Night

I’m a little surprised to see a new Alex Easton story. The first one seemed complete in itself. But novella series have been very successful so I’m not too surprised that this is happening.

As you may remember, What Moves the Dead was neat little re-working of “The Fall of the House of Usher”, with added homicidal mushrooms. It co-starred Miss Eugenia Potter, a thinly disguised version of Beatrix of the same surname, who was actually an expert on mushrooms. That book also provided us with an introduction to Alex’s status as a Sworn Soldier; that is, someone assigned female at birth who has taken up a male identity on becoming a soldier. That was a lot to fit into one novella.

What Feasts at Night has difficultly developing that theme. Miss Potter once again makes an appearance, but there are few mushrooms to be examined and none of them are homicidal. Instead she is there as an excuse for being out in the wilds of Gallacia, and because of her ongoing and rather cute relationship with Alex’s batman, Angus.

The Ushers, of course, have no role in the new story.

As for Alex, we hear rather more about the horrors of war than the horrors of gender transition. Everyone seems perfectly happy to accept Alex as a man. Indeed, the Widow Botezatu, the peasant woman that Alex hires as a housekeeper for his hunting lodge, treats him with exactly the same amount of disdain that she would have for an assigned-male member of the minor nobility who has taken up soldiery. The only person who expects Alex to be treated in any other way is Alex because, like any other trans person, he can’t forget who he is. That’s a nice touch that I appreciated.

So what is T Kingfisher planning for what will presumably be an ongoing series of Alex Easton novellas? Well, they will probably be neat little horror stories based on European folklore. Having come from a Ruritanian country allows Kingfisher to borrow from many different European countries, which I am sure will be useful as the series develops.

That may be the plan. But I’d like to suggest another one. Alex is clearly a man of the world. He has sufficient means to travel, and he clearly has done. It would be interesting, I think, to see him and Angus in environments other than the dark woods of their native country. Alex is certainly fond of Paris:

Paris, when we left, had been in full glory. Much is made of springtime there, but for my money, a warm autumn is just as spectacular, and you don’t trip over nearly as many poets.

Ouch! That was sharply observed. Alex has clearly also been to Finland as he knows the Finns well.

I’ve always had a soft spot for Finns. Some claim they’re unfriendly, but every one that I’ve met has been quite pleasant, if reserved. They have the quiet confidence of a people who know that, at any moment, they could strap on skis, go into the woods, and take out an entire squad of enemy soldiers before anyone knows they are there.

Yeah, that’s Finns alright. For some strange reason, Alex isn’t much taken with salmiakki. Clearly no one has persuaded him to try terva yet.

Anyway, my point is that taking Alex out of the woods would give plenty of opportunity for more observations of this type. It may also bring Alex’s trans status more to the fore. Because the more civilized people thing they are, the more daft social mores they tend to come up with.

book cover
Title: What Feasts at Night
By: T Kingfisher
Publisher: Titan
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

Queering Faith in Fantasy Literature

One of the great things about the ‘Perspectives on Fantasy’ series of academic books being produced by the Centre for Fantasy and the Fantastic at the University of Glasgow is that all the books get a paperback edition at a price that mere humans can afford. You do have to wait about a year after the publication of the hardcover, but you will get it. I’ve been eagerly awaiting Taylor Driggers’ book, and am pleased I can finally own a copy.

This being an academic book series, it is a bit heavy going. Driggers leans heavily on the theory of deconstruction as propounded by Jacques Derrida. It also helps to have some knowledge of the work on gender by Judith Butler. Those two I can manage. As for the feminist theologies of Hélène Cixous, Luce Irigaray, Marcella Althaus-Reid and Linn Marie Tonstad, nope, I’d never heard of them either. Consequently I was required to take Driggers’ word as to what their positions were, which is not ideal when reading academic works, but thankfully that didn’t matter too much.

Cixous, by the way, seems like my sort of feminist. Driggers quotes her as saying, “we have to be careful not to lapse smugly and blindly into an essentialist ideological interpretation between man and woman.” I might need to read some of her work.

Deconstruction, of course, is one of those things that the ‘Anti-Woke’ love to complain about. It doesn’t help that it is not an easy concept to understand, and is often poorly explained by academics. One of the best explanations I have found is this essay by Catherine Turner on a legal website. She describes deconstruction as “an on-going process of questioning the accepted basis of meaning”. That makes it sound very like the scientific method, because no matter what current science accepts as true, a good scientist will always question that orthodoxy.

Of course this is anathema to authoritarians, because they love to roll out “fundamental truths” in support of their position of supremacy. This is very much true of organized religion.

Inevitably a book titled Queering Faith in Fantasy Literature also leans heavily on Queer Theory. That sometimes gives me pause for thought, because I’ve seen rather too many examples of people doing versions of, “I’m going to give a queer reading of this text because it will be fun and I want to, even though there is no other justification for it.” Thankfully, Driggers doesn’t go there. He also provides a rationale for something that has been puzzling me for a while.

Here in the UK we have a history of using “queer” as a synonym for the alphabet soup of LGBTQIA+ and variants thereof. But a US-based history group that I follow has recently had a massive internal fight over the use of “queer” as an umbrella term because, so many members say, it is trans-exclusive. Also there was a panel at the recent Nebulas Conference that specifically used “queer and trans” in the title. Driggers cites Cáel M Keegan as pointing out that Queer Theory has an “insistence on the instability and incoherence of sex and gender identity”. That in turn can lead to an insistence that gender identity is purely a choice, which is clearly at odds with the lived experience of many (though not all) trans people.

One final thing before I stop talking about theory and get back to the book. Having written an essay on queer gods for the most recent Academia Lunare publication, I was interested to see what Driggers made of gods in fantasy. As it turned out, he led me to a quote from The Left Hand of Darkness that I wish I had used in that essay because it perfectly encapsulates what I was trying to say:

If it were proven that there is no God there would be no religion. No Handdara, no Yomesh, no hearthgods, nothing. But also if it were proven that there is a God, there would be no religion…

Le Guin, a genius as always.

But wait, I hear you say, The Left Hand of Darkness is science fiction, what is it doing in a book about fantasy? Well that depends on what you mean by fantasy. Driggers has a very expansive view of the term. His book focuses primarily on three texts, of which Le Guin’s is one. The other two are Angela Carter’s The Passion of New Eve, which is also generally classed as science fiction, and ‘Til We Have Faces by C S Lewis.

I have spent a lot of time thinking about The Left Hand of Darkness in terms of what it has to say about gender. I have tended to forget that it has a lot to say about religion as well, and is infused with Le Guin’s fascination with Taoism. Driggers makes the point that it is the absence of a gender binary on Gethen that allows the Gethenians to develop a religion that is not patriarchal, or even obsessed with stereotyped gender roles, as so many Earthly religions are.

The Passion of New Eve is also fairly obviously about religion. The title makes that clear, and Mother’s transformation of Evelyn into Eve is very much intended to be the foundation of a new, feminist religion. The book certainly pokes away at essentialist ideas of gender that can underpin “goddess religion”, but Driggers seems unaware of the nascent ideas of transphobia within feminism at the time the book was written, which makes his analysis of the text less useful.

That leaves us with ‘Til We Have Faces, a book that I had largely ignored because Lewis is notoriously a Christian apologist and a misogynist. However, it is his last novel, and Driggers suggests that it has a far more interesting approach to religion than Lewis’s other works. Here are a couple of choice quotes:

She [Ungit] is a black stone, without head or hands or face.

…pigeons, which are specially sacred to Ungit.

Cybele, like many near-Eastern gods, was represented by a black stone rather than a statue. And doves were specially sacred to Ishtar. Lewis has clearly been reading up on Mesopotamian religion.

I was so impressed by Driggers’ description of ‘Til We Have Faces that I have bought a copy. Hopefully I’ll get time to read it soon.

So were does this leave us? Queering Faith in Fantasy Literature is a difficult read, but a rewarding one if you have the necessary academic background and an interest in the subject matter. I was very pleased with Driggers’ nuanced approach to the issues, and very much applaud his willingness to question doctrine and seek to create a Christianity that is less patriarchal and more welcoming to women, queers and minorities of all sorts.

As to the general thesis, fantastic fiction is absolutely a tool for asking “how might things be different?” and as such is ideal for the sort of theological thought experiments that Driggers’ champions. Because of this it is rather a shame that so much ‘religion’ in fantasy is nothing of the sort. Perhaps this is why Driggers had to pick his examples from the field of science fiction.

book cover
Title: Queering Faith in Fantasy Literature
By: Taylor Driggers
Publisher: Bloomsbury Academic
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

Waypoint Seven

Here’s one you may not have heard of. Xan van Rooyen is a South African non-binary person currently living in Finland. Xan and I have been on a number of panels together at Nordic conventions, and at this year’s Finncon we will be discussing Queer Fantasies. Waypoint Seven, however, is not exactly a fantasy, it is a space opera with magic.

The book, by the way, is published by Mirari Press. You probably won’t have heard of them either. They are a relatively new small press based in Cape Town. I know how tough it is to start a publishing company, and I wish them well on their journey. Especially as they have a commitment to publishing diverse voices.

As to the book, well, the universe is under threat. It is space opera, right. One of the more technologically advanced civilisations has sent missions out through the universe looking for a solution to the problem that threatens their survival. These ‘wayfarers’ have been given strict Prime Directive instructions.

Waypoint Seven is one of their targets. To date, three missions have been sent there. All have been lost.

Meanwhile, on the planet that has been named Waypoint Seven, magic is literally falling from the skies, from a rent in the universe. Runo and his friends live by scavenging this bounty. They work for a vicious gang boss called Malikin who has a reputation for abusing his underlings. They’d love to run, but they need money to do so, and keeping profits from Malikin is a dangerous business. It doesn’t help that Runo is a member of a minority culture in their city, and liable to be executed by the city’s racist high priestess if he’s found out.

Then, one day, an angel falls from the sky.

As you can see, there is a lot going on here. It may surprise you to learn that the book is a novella. Given the amount of worldbuilding that van Rooyen has done, I could feel a novel straining to burst out of the confines of this little book. Then again, novellas are popular these days, and if you are interested in trying a new author, perhaps a shorter book is more appealing.

Anyway, I hope you do. After the first couple of chapters, there’s a breakneck pace to this book. Also it asks interesting questions about how people respond to looming disaster. And if that isn’t topical these days, I don’t know what is.

book cover
Title: Waypoint Seven
By: Xan van Rooyen
Publisher: Mirari Press
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

Unexploded Remnants

When I first started writing book reviews, I could count the number of trans authors active in the speculative fiction field on the fingers of one hand. These days they are everywhere. So welcome, Elaine Gallagher, previously best known as a Scottish poet, but now the latest in the stable of novella writers for Tor.com.

Unlike Waypoint Seven (also reviewed in this issue), Unexploded Remnants is one of those books that focuses tightly on the plot, leaving only vague sketches of the vast galactic canvas against which it is set. Alien species are introduced in a sentence and then never heard of again. Our heroine, Alice, goes fleeing through wormhole gateways at dizzying speed, briefly leaving a few footprints on a new world each time, before heading off somewhere new.

Why so much running? Well one of the major influences on the book is Indiana Jones. Alice thinks she has scored a bargain from an antique dealer in a bazar. But before she has a chance to celebrate her fortune she finds herself being chased by an ever-increasing collection of bad guys who are keen to separate her from her prize, preferably with a clean laser cut.

So Alice ends up getting chased over the galaxy, and inevitably there are interludes of extreme violence during which various AIs deploy ridiculously powerful weaponry at speeds mere humans cannot follow. It is very space opera. Reminds me a bit of Banks.

Gallagher, like the Wachowskis, seems obsessed with Lewis Caroll and white rabbits. There is Alice, obviously. Her personal AI is called Bugs. She spends a lot of time going down rabbit holes. I’m not sure if there was supposed to be a purpose to this, but it was fun.

The point of the story, however, is much more serious. The treasure that Alice has picked up is not just a fantastically powerful weapon. It is a soldier in a genocidal war that ended millennia ago. The point of the book is that the most likely response to an atrocity is a retaliatory atrocity, and so on through a cycle of ever-escalating violence. The only way to win such a conflict is to refuse to play. It is a message that many parts of the world need to hear, and none of them seem to want to.

book cover
Title: Unexploded Remnants
By: Elaine Gallagher
Publisher: Tor.com
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

Tolkien Lecture 2024

It was that time of year again, so off I went to Oxford for the annual Tolkien Lecture on Fantasy Literature. This year was a bit special. That was partly because at long last a memorial to Professor Tolkien was to be unveiled in Pembroke College. That was as much a project as the lecture series itself: something that Gabriel Shenk, Will Badger and their colleagues had pressed the college for from their student days. Because really Pembroke should make more of its most famous Fellow.

The other reason this year was special was because the lecture was to be given by a chap called Neil Gaiman, of whom you may have heard. Whereas previous lectures had all been held on Pembroke’s premises (they do have a lecture hall), this one was planned for Oxford Town Hall. I gather than tickets sold out on the first day they went on sale.

Being a Friend of the Lecture Series (not to mention an old friend of the lecturer), I got a freebie. That also meant an invitation to the memorial unveiling. So on a sunny afternoon in Oxford I ended up in the Master’s Garden eating cream teas and sipping bubbly in the company of the Great and Good. That included quite a few of the Tolkien family, because the memorial had been designed by the Professor’s nephew, Tim. Much to my delight, it also included Kim Stanley Robinson, whom I’d not seen in ages, and Geoff Ryman, so I was able to thank him for HIM.

Also present were Maria Dahvana Headley and little Grim, because they are part of the Tolkien Lecture Family now. Roz Kaveney, being a Pembroke alumnus herself, was there, and Neil had asked her to write a poem for the unveiling. A surprise to me was the presence of historian, Kate Lister. I hope I didn’t fangirl too badly. And if you have not heard the episode of her podcast that Neil guested on, you really should give it a listen. It is hilarious.

The memorial was duly unveiled. I’ve included a photo of it with this report. Inevitably reply guys on social media were jumping on my posts complaining that it is ugly. That’s art for you though. If you haven’t upset some idiots in the process, you are probably not doing it right. I can’t find a copy of Roz’s poem online, possibly because internet search is rubbish these days.

Neil’s speech was very Neil. If you have heard him talk before you’ll have some idea of what it was like, even though each speech is quite different. Juliet McKenna has a post about it here, in which she picks up on her mention of the idea that the only people opposed to escapism are jailers (via CS Lewis, credited to Tolkien).

Neil spent much of the speech talking about his childhood, and how he got into reading fantasy. This led to favorite authors from his childhood, one of whom was Nicholas Stuart Gray. For those of you who missed the social media storm this produced, Gray was a 20th Century trans man. He’d had a fairly successful career as an actress in the 1930s and 40s, but during the War he took the opportunity to disappear and reinvent himself as a man. Many fine books ensued.

That’s very early, as far as modern trans history is concerned. For comparison, Michael Dillon, who pioneered medical transition for trans guys, also transitioned during WW2. Gray would have had no idea that such things were possible when he began his journey, but he made it nonetheless.

The fact of Gray’s transition was known to very few people. Neil had to do quite a bit of digging to get to the truth, including ordering a copy of Gray’s death certificate. That’s a fascinating document because laws about gender transition were decades away when Gray died. It gives his sex as male, but cites one of the causes of death as cancer of the ovaries. There is a fascinating note on that: “NB Sex Change 1959”.

Dillon was outed in the Daily Express in May 1958. Gray presumably read that story, and may have learned from it that medical transition was a possibility. If he did, he clearly wasted no time in availing himself of what was possible.

These days Gray’s books are all out of print. This is a great shame, as they are much better than the books written by a certain well known transphobe. Hopefully they can be brought back into print, though as is often the case with deceased authors, there are legal issues to be resolved.

Oxford Town Hall, by the way, is a beautiful building. I hope we can go back there again sometime soon.

After that we all trooped back to Pembroke for dinner in Hall. I was lucky enough to end up sat next to Carolynne Larrington, and we had an interesting chat about Spear and mediaeval Welsh literature.

A recording of Neil’s speech will be made available on the Tolkien Lecture website in due course.

The Book Blinders

Our story begins in 2011 with the British Library’s first ever exhibition of science fiction. John Clute, inevitably, was called in to advise on the project. But he ended up doing rather more than that, including lending some books from his own collection for display. Because the British Library (BL), an institution tasked with being a repository for the nation’s literature, does a rather shoddy job of preserving books.

The BL is entitled to receive one copy of every book published in the UK. I know, I have to send them copies of every Wizard’s Tower publication. Given the choice, they prefer to have hardcovers. But for some inexplicable reason, over many, many decades, it has been the BL’s policy to remove the dust jacket from each book before storing it.

Consider, for a moment, a typical Wizard’s Tower hardcover. It is our policy to use the cover of the book to showcase the cover art. For legal reasons we have to have the ISBN bar code box on the back. But aside from that there is nothing but art. No title, no author name, no publisher logo, no blurb. All of that is only on the dust jacket. Which means, if you take the dust jacket off, you can’t tell what the book is without opening it and reading some of it.

That, of course, is by no means the worst of the BL’s crimes. The technology required to print the cover art on the actual cover without it costing a fortune is fairly new. In days gone by, covers tended to only carry the title and author name. Everything else, including the cover art, was on the dust jacket. Stripping off the dust jacket separates the book from the cover art which, in some cases is a fine piece of work by a famous artist. Because publishers tended not to credit the cover artist inside the book, without the dust jacket we may not even know who the artist was.

It get worse, and that is why Clute has written The Book Blinders. In a state of not inconsiderable fury at the BL over their wanton vandalism, he has done some research to find examples of the true horror of what has been perpetrated on our national literature. Initially this work took the form of posts on Farcebook whenever a new suitably awful example was found. Now there is an entire book of them. Hopefully it will stand as a dreadful warning to librarians the world over, and an example of What Not To Do.

One of the most egregious examples in the book is Katharine Burdekin’s Swastika Night (written under the name of Murray Constantine because selling SF as a woman was even harder in 1937). The book is set a few years into the future, and describes the awful consequences for the world of the triumph of Nazi Germany. Fearing that a mere image would not get the message across, the publishers (Gollancz) devoted the entire dust jacket (front, both flaps and back) to an essay summarizing the plot. Legend has it that it was written by Victor Gollancz himself, though Malcolm Edwards says not. The BL has thrown away this vital part of the book.

‘Til We Have Faces by CS Lewis is referenced elsewhere in this issue where I discuss Taylor Driggers’ book on fantasy and religion. It should be clear from that, that the novel is a fairly serious endeavor. The first edition of the book had a long section on the back of the dust jacket in which the origins of the book (as a re-telling of Cupid and Psyche) are described, and Lewis himself explains his reasons for changing the story from the original. By the second edition, this had gone, and the publisher described the novel as a book for children. The BL has the first edition, but no dust jacket.

The first edition of Michael Moorcock’s Behold the Man has, for a dust jacket illustration, a half-face photograph of the author. Behold the man indeed. Yet again, the BL did not see fit to preserve this fascinating authorial statement.

I could go on, but you get the idea. Also that’s enough spoilers. Because the book necessarily contains photographs of all the dust jackets that it discusses, it is quite expensive. But maybe you could borrow it from a library. It is a hardcover. Make sure you get a copy with the dust jacket.

book cover
Title: The Book Blinders
By: John Clute
Publisher: Norstrilia Press
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

Doctor Who 15-1

I’ve not been a great fan of Doctor Who over the past decade or so. That’s partly because I seem to be allergic to almost everything that Steven Moffat writes. But also I just didn’t get it. I mostly wasn’t very invested in the characters or the stories. I’m pleased to say that, with the new season, that’s all changed.

There have been a lot of complaints on social media about the current season, especially the finale. Some of them are just dudebros frothing about the Doctor having gone Woke, as if the whole idea of fighting Daleks wasn’t being anti-Fascist. But a lot of it is from people who, for some inexplicable reason, want the stories to make sense. People, this is Doctor Who, it is a show about an incredibly old being with two hearts and indeterminate gender who bums around space and time in a police phone box fighting evil. His main weapon is a screwdriver that seems able to do anything the plot requires of it. Do you really expect it to make sense?

Jelly baby?

Of course previous seasons have, to some extent, bought into the idea that making sense is something the show should strive towards. Various actors have played the Doctor as being quite a serious chap, with the weight of the universe on his shoulders. Not so Ncuti Gatwa. His Doctor is delightfully camp and flippant, and consequently everything around him is less serious too.

I mean, we started with singing goblins. It was ridiculous, and hilarious, and it set the tone for the series. We had space babies and a snot monster. We had aliens who wanted to conquer the world through cosplay. And we had the glorious Jinxx Monsoon eating up the scenery with impeccable style. How is any of this supposed to make sense?

And yet…

“73 Yards” was about the dangers of Fascism. “Dot and Bubble” was about how racism warps people’s sense of reality. “Boom” was about the commercialization of war for profit. Which just goes to show that you don’t have to be serious to make a serious point.

Now you can fairly argue that many of these points were clumsily made, and that consequently the show is tending to lose politically committed viewers that should be supporting it. But this is the BBC we are talking about. We shouldn’t complain about the talking pig because the only language it knows is English.

There were no episodes that were specifically about trans rights. And yet there is an openly trans character in a fairly major role. The show itself is unashamedly queer, and introduced a male love interest for the Doctor in a way that inhabited the traditional tropes of Regency romance, the setting for that episode.

Having watched the Doctor Who Unleashed episodes that followed each show, it is clear that there are a lot of queer folks working backstage too. Oh, and Russell lives some 15 miles south of me, while Steffan from Unleashed is from Glanaman, which is the next valley east of me up into the Bannau Brycheiniog. Local boys. Very proud of them, we are.

So try to relax, folks. This is not hard science fiction. It isn’t even remotely firm science fiction. It is wibbly-wobbly timey-wimey camp adventure, that occasionally shows its teeth. And in doing so, pipes a little ray of sunshine into the awful right-wing propaganda machine that the BBC has become.

3 Body Problem – Netflix

I gave up on the first of Cixin Liu’s novels because it was very slow, and reminded me of the sort of science fiction that I read when I was a teenager. Consequently I can’t comment on the quality of Benioff & Weiss’ TV show as an adaptation of the books. As I understand it, they have diverged radically from the original. So I’m going to judge it in isolation.

Whereas what little I read of Cixin Liu reminded me of Asimov at this most expository, the Netflix TV series is very character driven. The ‘Oxford Five’, as I believe they are known, are all interesting in their own right, and their various interactions are much more interesting than the science, which is just as well.

The plot occasionally shows signs of the script team having had to condense a trilogy of fat novels into very few TV episodes, and the CGI is sometimes rather wonky. But the series maintains a high level of drama throughout. I certainly finished each episode wanting to watch the next one straight away.

I thought the acting was pretty good. Benedict Wong steals the show, of course, but I was very impressed with Alex Sharp as Will Downing. It is a great part.

Something that may cause problems for other viewers is the way that the show teeters between trying to be a hard SF story and verging into fantasy. I’m not in a position to judge the physics, but I’m assuming that was taken from Cixin and is therefore good. Certainly the show has an impressive collection of science fiction ideas that it plays with. But the technology deployed by the aliens is very much in the Indistinguishable from Magic ballpark, regardless of how much technobabble is deployed in support of it.

I understand that there is a Chinese TV series available on Amazon Prime. That supposedly adheres much more closely to the original books, and also keeps the largely Chinese cast. Providing Western characters to front the show was probably necessary to finance a version for Western TV, but I can quite see why many people prefer something that hasn’t been wrenched from its cultural context. I hope to give that a try.

Having said that, I am also looking forward to a second season of the NetFlix 3 Body Problem. I am doing so with some trepidation because, by most reports, Benioff and Weiss missed sticking the landing on A Game of Thrones by a margin measurable only in units used by astrophysicists. But we shall see. Season 1 was good enough for me to give them a chance.

Furiosa

Furiosa is a prequel to Mad Max: Fury Road. It tells the story of the titular character from her girlhood through to become the capable woman that we know from the earlier film. It is, in other words, cashing in on the success of Fury Road. But is it worth it? Well…

The first thing to note is that our heroine is not played by Charlize Theron. The movies can do amazing things with ageing actors, but making them younger is much harder. So young girl Furiosa is played by Alyla Browne, and the rest of the time she’s Anya Taylor-Joy.

Taylor-Joy is hot property as far as actresses go these days. She’s had a bunch of high-profile roles, and looks set of play Paul’s sister in Dune 3 if it happens. I can totally see her as Illyana Rasputin, and indeed as Princess Peach in the Super Mario movie. I’m much less convinced of her as a young Charlize Theron. She’s too petite and cute. On the other hand, having seen Furiosa, I am very keen to see her play Joan of Arc, because I think she’d be absolutely perfect.

Of course the main villain of this film cannot be Immortan Joe, because he has to be still around during Fury Road. So the film introduces a rival warlord called Dementus, who is camped up wonderfully by Chris Hemsworth (who actually gets to play an Australian for once). This includes him getting to do a Ben Hur thing in a Roman chariot pulled by motorbikes. (Don’t ask how that works, this is Mad Max, not reality.) I loved the fact that he got to wear a red cloak for part of the film.

The core of the film is, of course, the vehicle action. There is lots of it. As special effects go, it is very well done. But the visual jokes were all done in Fury Road. Furiosa has nothing new, just more of the same. You can tell that the filmmakers were unhappy with what they’d done, because they put a whole lot of clips from Fury Road in as an epilogue. It was obvious which film was better.

The other thing that is notable about the film is the change of emphasis. Fury Road was a film about hope. It is about Furiosa’s quest to find the “Green Place” where she lived before she was kidnapped. We now know (spoiler) that it no longer exists, but Furiosa finding that out doesn’t change the hopeful attitude of the film, because the characters still believe that a better world is possible.

Furiosa, on the other hand, is a film about loss of hope. Dementus doesn’t believe that hope is possible. Furiosa, perhaps, ends up working for Joe because she has lost hope of getting home. Praetorian Jack, the kindly truck driver who takes her under his wing and teaches her everything he knows, is very obviously doomed to die, if only because he isn’t in Fury Road.

“Where are you going, so full of hope? There is no hope!” – Dementus

Maybe Furisoa is a film for our time. Given the ongoing rise of Fascism around the world, and the losses suffered by Green parties in the recent European elections, perhaps a film about loss of hope is playing into the zeitgeist. Who needs The Mighty Thor when you can have Dementus? But Furiosa is a prequel, not a sequel. It has meaning only in that it informs what happens in Fury Road. We need to remember that. There’s more to life than car chases.

Editorial – June 2024

It has been an other month of not getting much reading done. Or at least not much reading I can talk about. The best reading time for me is always when I’m on trains or aircraft. That bodes well for this month as I’m off to Finland tomorrow and then France, so I’ll have plenty of good reading time.

Having thought about the practicalities, I’m not going to put out an issue in July. I’ll be very busy trying to fit a month’s worth of day job, and last minute Worldcon prep, into the small part of July when I will be home. Also, if I just write stuff and get some of it online, I’ll be better placed to get an issue out in August, including a Worldcon report.

Not that I’m hugely looking forward to Worldcon. Obviously I’m looking forward to selling books and seeing a whole bunch of friends, especially Kevin. But I’m seeing a lot of people writing furiously about what WSFS Should Do, or indeed Must Do, and very little consideration of what it will take to get these ideas past the Business Meeting, let alone make them work in practice. I suspect that the Business Meeting in Glasgow will be a train wreck, and everyone will be Very Angry again.

Please remember, folks, political change does not happen just because you want it to, or because you have written an angry blog post setting out the moral case for your ideas to be adopted. You have to put in the work. Because if you don’t, you can be sure that the people with far less scruples than you will end up winning again.

Issue #61

This is the May 2024 issue of Salon Futura. Here are the contents.


  • Cover: Green(ock) Woman: This issue's cover is Green(ock) Woman, by Iain J Clark

  • Ninth Life: The latest novel in Stark Holborn's Factus Sequence focuses on the lives of Gabi Ortiz: child general, rebel commander, and wanted murderer

  • The Brides of High Hill: Cleric Chih is back on the road again. But where is Almost Brilliant? And what about all those dead women...

  • Thornhedge: There is a princess trapped in a tower. Goddess help us all if she ever gets out.

  • The Association of Welsh Writing in English Conference: Cheryl is off into the wilds of Wales for a weekend of academia

  • The Word: Is there science fiction written and published in Wales? Of course there is. But because it is written and pubished in Wales, you probably haven't heard of it--until now

  • Cunning Folk and Familiar Spirits: Could witch trials in the early modern period be evidence of a survival of shamanistic practices among the country folk of Britain? Emma Wilby thinks so.

  • X-Men ’97: The X-Men animated series is back. Can comics' greatest soap opera have another hit? Or, like the movies, is this another X-Men disaster?

  • Star Trek Discovery – The Final Season: Discovery had boldly gone and re-invented the past, and explored the future. Now we say goodbye to Michael Burnham and her crew. Has the series found its feet at last?

  • Editorial – May 2024: In which there are new things.

Cover: Green(ock) Woman

This issue’s cover is the last of the Iain J Clark covers that I’m running to help promote the Glasgow Worldcon (and, of course, Iain’s work). This one is called Green(ock) Woman. I have no idwa what Scottish thistles smell like, having never got close enough to one to find out, but I love the concept.

As usual, you can find a larger, unadorned version of the art below.


The Glasgow committee noted:

Glasgow 2024 has been incredibly privileged to have been supported by the donated artwork of Iain J Clark. He was a Hugo nominee in the ‘Best Fan Artist’ category for three consecutive years and he won the BFSA award for best artwork in 2020 with ‘Ship Building Over the Clyde’ and in 2021 with the ‘Glasgow Green Woman’ which are available along with his other beautiful work at https://www.etsy.com/shop/iainjclarkart

If you want to know more about the Glasgow Worldcon, their website is: https://glasgow2024.org/.

Ninth Life

If you, like me, have been avidly following this series from Stark Holborn, you will know that the first two books were called Ten Low and Hel’s Eight. You too many have been expecting the new book to have a Six in the title, and be somewhat bemused by the reversal of the counting sequence. However, there is sense to this (or at least what passes for sense on Factus, the Outlaw Moon).

Ninth Life is not a book about Ten, or Hel the Converter, or whatever she is calling herself right now. It is about Gabi; that is, Gabriella Ortiz, Implacabilis, Hero of the Battle of Kin, the Dead General. Gabi, you may remember, was a child soldier, a Captain-General of the Minority Force, genetically engineered to be a perfect weapon in the armed forces of the Accord. Once the war she was created for was over (oh, Ten, you did that, didn’t you), the Minority Force was surplus to requirements and the Accord sought to destroy them. But Gabi ended up on Factus, where she died, met Ten, and met them. Which is how she became the rebel leader known as Nine Lives.

The thing about Factus is that it is home to the Ifs, them, the mysterious alien creatures who seem to live off, thrive off, probability. The Ifs exist across all possible worlds and, if you can call upon them in just the right way, they can ensure that the path through the multiverse that you end up in is the one in which the outcome you wanted, no matter how improbable, has actually happened.

Needless to say, calling upon them is a very imprecise science. Also, they are not exactly the most reliable of allies. But they do seem to like the plucky rebels of Factus, perhaps because their cause is so obviously hopeless.

The trouble is, the existence of the Ifs is now known outside of Factus. In particular it has come to the attention of the fabulously wealthy mining magnate, Lutho Xoon. He believes that the power of the Ifs can make him immortal, and he will stop at nothing to get it.

Much of this you should know from the first two books. Where has Holborn chosen to take the story next?

The first thing to note is that, because this is a book about Gabi, it is less of a Western and more of a war story. Gabi is, after all, a soldier. As we shall see through the course of the book, she spends most of her lives fighting against Xoon, his mercenaries, and the forces of the Accord. It is, inevitably, a hopeless task.

Our story begins in the future with Gabi crash-landing on Jaspal-Pero Mining Satellite V (Jaypea V to its inhabitants). There she falls into the custody of Havemercy Grey, a young deputy in the Accord law enforcement service. Gabi is wanted for the murder of one Lutho Xoon. The reward is fantastically high. Hav’s family are dirt poor. She has to try to collect. But every bounty hunter in the system is going to be trying to stop her and claim the reward for themselves.

As for Gabi, she’s cool about the whole thing. When the Ifs saved her on Factus, they gave her nine lives. Well, eight more anyway. She’s on her last. Given what she has done, it seems likely that it will be a short one. So she agrees to go with Hav on the condition that she is allowed to tell the story of how she spent those other seven lives.

That in itself would make for a fascinating book, but Holborn ramps up the complexity by adding another layer of abstraction. Military Proctor Idrisi Blake is an employee of the Accord. He has been assigned to investigate the so-called Luck Wars, and in particular the impossible story of Gabriella Ortiz. Of course no one can really have nine lives, so presumably there have been multiple rebel leaders over time who assumed the identity of Ortiz. Or perhaps she was just very lucky…

Blake has in his possession several important pieces of evidence. Others he has to track down in the decrepit and corrupted computer systems on backwater worlds such as Jaypea-V. As fast as he can find them, these records seem to disappear, sometimes shortly after he has read them. But he does, at least, have his own copy of the most important source: the Testimony of Havemercy Grey. It is a strange document. Ortiz’s life, as filtered through Grey, seems too crazy to be true. Also, if Grey is to be believed, while in the middle of a story, Ortiz occasionally addresses Blake in person, as if she knows he will be reading what Grey writes down.

If that hasn’t whetted your appetite for these books, I don’t know what else I can say. Holborn has created something amazing here. The voices of the Western in the first two books, and the War Novel in this one, are beautifully rendered. The Ifs are a truly fascinating alien species. Lutho Xoon is exactly the right villain for a story being written now.

But, you know, just in case, and because style is everything with these books, there is one more voice on the page. It belongs to DJ Lester Sixofus of the non-stop wire show, ‘Perpetual Notions’. Lester exists in Hav’s timeline, and he’s keen to keep his listeners up to date with the story of how the notorious Nine Lives is finally being brought to justice by a plucky young deputy from a backwater moon. Lester, I am fairly sure, was inspired by DJ Crash Crash who provides updates on the hunt for Cindi Mayweather on Janelle Monae’s classic concept album, The Electric Lady.

Power Up, y’all.

Ninth Life will be published on July 23rd. Stark kindly sent me an advance copy.

book cover
Title: Ninth Life
By: Stark Holborn
Publisher: Titan
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

The Brides of High Hill

You know the drill by now. Cleric Chih and their neixin, Almost Brilliant, are somewhere out in the world. They get into an adventure. Stories are told, and a mystery is solved. Except, of course, if Nghi Vo did the same thing with every story in the Singing Hills cycle, it would get quite dull. So she doesn’t. While every story has those core elements, each one proceeds very differently. Sometimes we are even deprived of the company of Almost Brilliant, as is the case for most of The Brides of High Hill, though I hope Vo won’t do that too often because the neixin is very much the star of the show.

The Brides of High Hill, as you might perhaps expect from the title, starts of with something of a Bluebeard theme to it. Cleric Chih has fallen in with a party on the road. The Phams, a somewhat impoverished noble family, are taking their young daughter, Nhung, to get married. She is to wed Lord Guo, of the city of Doi Cao. He is very wealthy, and very old. He has had several wives before. He also has a son, whom Nhung is told is insane. Of course the young man is handsome, and he tries to give Nhung a terrible warning.

Nhung’s parents are far too keen to avail themselves of part of Lord Guo’s fortune, and his impressive hospitality, to worry about the fate of their daughter. Fortunately for Nhung, she has taken a liking to Cleric Chih, and clerics have sufficient status in society for our hero to be of some small assistance to the unfortunate girl.

You can see where all of this is going. Except of course you can’t, because this is a Singing Hills novella, so you know that there will be a twist somewhere towards the end of the story.

This latest installment in the series is somewhat darker than previous books, though it is apparently nowhere near as dark as the legendary baby-eating story that Vo talks about in her recent appearance on The Coode Street Podcast. Tor.com are probably right to have passed on it, because the market these days seems to be very much in favour of fluffiness, but I do hope that it gets to see print at some point in the future.

Beyond that there is not a lot I can say, except that I love these books, and I will keep buying them as long as Vo keeps churning new ones out.

book cover
Title: The Brides of High Hill
By: Nghi Vo
Publisher: Tor.com
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

Thornhedge

Once upon a time there was a princess in a tower.

That, you might think, has already been done to death. But writers are endlessly inventive and, in Thornhedge, T Kingfisher has found a new angle. What if, she asked, the princess has been put there for a reason? What if people are terrified of what might happen if she gets out.

This, then, is the story of Toadling, a human princess who was stolen away by wicked fairies shortly after her birth. Thanks to the weird way time works in Faerie, she grew up happily amongst a group of pond folk, and she learned a little magic on the way. Meanwhile, in the royal castle where she was born, and a changeling has been left, all hell was about to be let loose. Only one person can prevent it.

Our story begins hundreds of years later. The castle containing the sleeping faerie princess has long since vanished behind a wall of thorns and brambles. Toadling still watches over it, just in case. And here, along the road, comes Halim, a young Muslim knight who is far more interested in books than tournaments, and who has found references to a mysterious lost kingdom and a hidden tower containing a sleeping girl.

Toadling has fought to keep her changeling foster sister contained for centuries. People she can manage. Magic she can counter. But can she fight the power of story?

Despite what budding writers may think, having the idea is only a small part of the job. Lots of people could have come up with a similar take on Sleeping Beauty. Few, if any, could have told it the way Kingfisher does. And that is the difference between an ordinary story and a great one.

“Tomorrow,” said Halim. “Tomorrow we will try to break the curse.”

“And if, as I keep saying, there is no curse?”

“Then I will brave the curse for you, Mistress Toadling. I have brought climbing equipment and an axe. The monk said that there aren’t many curses that can hold up to an axe.”

“He sounds very wise, this monk,” said Toadling. “I wish he’d been wise enough to tell you to stay away.”

“He is as curious as I am. It’s a dangerous thing, curiosity.”

book cover
Title: Thornhedge
By: T Kingfisher
Publisher: Tor.com
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura

The Association of Welsh Writing in English Conference

One of the interesting things about conquests and colonization is how language shifts as a result. England was conquered by the Normans in 1066. The Norman aristocracy continued to speak French for a long time thereafter, but the English people never adopted that language and eventually the nobility started speaking English. It took the Normans a lot longer to extend their conquest into Wales, and it wasn’t really until the time of Henry VIII that Wales became fully subsumed into the British state. People in Wales continued to speak Welsh right up until the 19th Century, when the Victorians decided that the Welsh should be forced to speak English, on pain of strict punishment. Since Devolution, the Welsh language has seen something of a revival, at least in official spheres, but the rise of English as a world language has made it hard to explain to young Welsh people why they should have to learn their native tongue.

What does all this mean for Welsh Literature? There are some who think that to count as such a work has to be written in Welsh. But if you insist on that strict definition you are ruling out, amongst much else, the entire oeuvre of Dylan Thomas, arguably the greatest Welsh poet ever. Not to mention the great Welsh fantasy and horror writer, Arthur Machen. So most people accept that Welsh literature can be written in English. They still argue over whether the author has to have been born in Wales, live in Wales, be eligible to play rugby for Wales, or any other definition of nationality, but Welsh Literature written in English is officially a thing. And that means that academics will study it.

So, an academic conference, at a lovely location in central Wales, and an opportunity to give a paper about Nicola’s Griffith’s brilliant novel, Spear. How could I resist?

Let’s start with the venue. Gregynog Hall is a mock-Tudor stately home situated in large grounds a few miles north of the town of Newtown in Powys. While the area has been occupied since at least the 12th century, the current building is only around 150 years old. The ‘half-timbered’ look is entirely artificial. Of rather more interest is that the whole thing was done using what, for the 19th century, was a new and unusual building material—concrete.

Prior to the reconstruction, there was a Jacobean mansion on the site. The builders left one room of that house standing, and built the new house around it. The so-called Blayney Room dates from 1636 and is entirely wood-paneled, with all sorts of interesting carvings that I would love to investigate more.

The Hall has extensive gardens (including several Redwood trees which just love the damp Welsh climate). I’m told that we got a superb view of the aurora on the Friday night. Sadly I had gone to bed and missed the whole thing.

One downside of the venue is that it is not very accessible. In particular the two conference rooms are on the second floor (third floor if you are American) and there is no lift. However, there is good wifi in the conference areas and the event is mostly hybrid.

This being Wales, much of the content was about poetry. We even had some well-known poets at the event, including the fabulous Taz Rahman. But there were things more in my wheelhouse as well. I was particularly impressed by the opening keynote from Dr. Mary Chadwick. She has just edited a new edition of Ellen, Countess of Castle Howel by Anna Maria Bennett. That’s a book you have probably never heard of, and indeed this is the first new edition since 1794, but it was a massive best-seller in its time, alongside works by Samuel Richardson and Henry Fielding. Along with Bennett’s six other works, it was almost certainly read with enthusiasm by the teenage Jane Austen. There were, after all, not many women novelists for her to read.

Bennett has been forgotten for many reasons, starting with her being a woman. She was also Welsh, hailing from Merthyr Tydfil with a family name of Evans. After an unhappy marriage to a Bristol man called Thomas Bennett, she ran away to London where she caught the eye of Admiral Thomas Pye. She was his mistress for many years, and turned to writing only when the relationship began to sour. All of her books were published after Pye’s death, and the income from them helped Bennett and her daughters survive. One of those daughters, Harriet, became an actress and mistress of the Duke of Hamilton.

I do love a bit of forgotten feminist history, and this was a fine example of the genre.

There were presentations from some current creative writing students. My friend Jo Lambert is working on a story about the legendary Welsh outlaw, Twm Siôn Cati, who seems much more interesting than the modern, sanitized versions of his story make out. Also Mari Elis Dunning has a forthcoming novel called Witsch, about an alleged witch from early modern Wales. The history of witch trials in Britain is fascinating for many reasons, one of which is the geographic distribution. While the Scots condemned thousands of alleged witches to death, and the English hundreds, the Welsh executed precisely 5. Mari argues that a Welsh witch would only be found guilty if she had fallen foul of the local nobility; otherwise she was a valued member of the community.

My own paper went down well enough, though it did suffer from being in the part of the schedule that was double-streamed. I also got to meet and chat to some of the great and good of Welsh publishing, which will hopefully be useful for Wizard’s Tower. I very much enjoyed the weekend, and look forward to going again next year.

The Word

One of the reasons I’m interested in the subject of Welsh Writing in English is to enable me to track down Welsh science fiction and fantasy. There have been a few science fiction novels written in Welsh. Not all of them have been translated into English. There are also Welsh people who are famous in the SF&F community: Al Reynolds, Jo Walton and Gareth Powell, for example. There are Welsh immigrants you will have heard of too, including Jasper Fforde, Stephanie Burgis and Tim Lebbon. Mostly these folks are unknown on the Welsh literary scene. But there are also people writing SF&F in Wales, and being published in Wales, who seem completely unknown in the wider SF&F world.

One such writer is JL George. A copy of her debut novel, The Word, was thrust into my hands at the AWEE conference (thanks Kirsti!). The book won the Rubery Book Award, which is an award for self-published books and books from small presses, in 2022. The Word is published by Parthian, a well-respected Welsh publisher that also does a lot of translations. I have a collection of Slovak fantasy stories that they did on my TBR pile.

I don’t know why George elected to go with a small Welsh mainstream publisher rather than an SF&F press, but I suspect it is because The Word is very much a Brexit novel. The subject matter would have been unpalatable to a London publisher, and impenetrable to one outside of the UK. This is a shame, because the book deserves to be much more widely read.

The Word is set in the near future in what Britain is likely to become if the Tories win the coming election, and was probably influenced by 1984. ‘Foreigners’ of all sorts are viewed with deep suspicion. We have always been at war with Europe (and occasionally random streets get bombed as an example of ‘European aggression’). The internet, and computers in general, were heavily restricted and eventually banned. Christian belief is becoming a social necessity.

Into this, George tosses some teenage mutants. Not, you will understand, people with fantastical powers who run around in gaudy costumes saving humanity. There is one sole mutation. It gives the mutant the power to force others to obey. If you use The Word, people will do what you tell them.

Nor is there a lovely old mansion in Westchester County where kindly Professor Xavier helps his young pupils come to terms with their abilities. Instead there is The Centre, a grim government establishment somewhere on the Welsh borders where mutant kids are brought in ‘for their own good’ and clipboard-armed people in white coats do experiments on them to see if The Word can be deployed in the service of the government.

The story switches back and fore in time as we discover something of how the world of the novel came to be, and get some backstory on the four inmates of The Centre: Rhydian, Jonno, Rachel and Cadi. We also get to meet May, the deaf teacher who has been employed to tutor the kids, and Irena, a Polish woman searching for a lost daughter. All of this is brought together in a satisfying way at the end.

From a science fiction point of view, there’s not a lot innovative about the book. Its portrayal of post-Brexit Britain as a small-minded, bigoted country, isolated from the world and in thrall to a far-right government is, however, the most brutal I have yet seen. For that alone, The Word deserves to be more widely read. In addition, George has that talent that all novelists wish for: the ability to keep you reading because you desperately want to know what happens next.

book cover
Title: The Word
By: J L George
Publisher: Parthian
Purchase links:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Bookshop.org UK
See here for information about buying books though Salon Futura
1 2 3 4 5 23